Welcome
Username or Email:

Password:




[ ]
[ ]
[ ]
Chatbox
You must be logged in to post comments on this site - please either log in or if you are not registered click here to signup


  • Stormmy
    Stormmy  3 months ago

    Randomly decided to check in after years and see talk of Doordie and Amel. Lots of fun memories! Arguably my first long time character, Narwyn, ended up closely aligned with Amel as his protege.

  • Lobi55
    Lobi55  5 months ago

  • Naerwen
    Naerwen  7 months ago

    Doordie was one of the best RP's I ever played with. His stories, with his character Amel, were amazing. Rich, deep, complex. I hope Doordie is doing well! You have a really great Uncle!

  • Great_Poet
    Great_Poet  7 months ago

    I remember Amel! Great player. Moby and he had a few fun showdowns.

  • Shards
    Shards  10 months ago

    @TheSaltyDemon, Yes I definately remember Doordie! Amel was one of the best rp'ed/complex characters on the server. Love that guy!

  • Payne
    Payne  10 months ago

    Absolutely remember him! Amel was a beast, he was one of the best rp'd villains of all time. How is he?

  • TheSaltyDemon
    TheSaltyDemon  10 months ago

    My uncle is Doordie, I wanna know if anyone remembers him or remembers his character Amel.

  • Shards
    Shards  1 year ago

    Happy new year!

  • Dizzy-D2
    Dizzy-D2  1 year ago

    Happy new year! #2025!!!

  • Edrick
    Edrick  1 year ago

    Merry Christmas


Forums
The Island of Thain :: Forums :: Technical Discussion
« Previous topic | Next topic »   

Create Undead vs Animate Dead

LAN_402 LAN_403
OccamsRazor
2:01:46 am GMT 02/13/11
OccamsRazor Registered Member #1490 Joined: 5:13:40 pm GMT 11/12/09
Posts: 71
Create Undead has the potential to be great, but unfortunately falls short, far short. When you analyze Create Undead, an 8th level wizard/sorcerer spell, it is surprising to find that it summons a creature that in any area aside from kobolds or goblins is going to get smashed or be just a momentary distraction while you run away.

However, when you look at the spell Animate dead, a 5th level wizard/sorcerer spell, it is incredible, as far as summons go. It actually helps you, it isn't immensely overpowered for areas, and provides the RP and mechanical backing to make it a worthwhile part of a spell book. This seems the reverse of how it should be. The lower level spell summons a creature that is superior in every way to the higher level spell. It would be a wonderful thing to see the higher level version of this spell beefed up a bit.

My idea, as it is mine it may not agree with everyone's, is that the spell Create Undead should be if the staff or builders do not have time to rework the entire thing and make it a new spell all together, is to make it work like Create Greater Undead for Clerics. That way there is an increase that is comparable to the level of caster doing the summoning.

Any response that wishes to argue RP vs Mechanics, please refrain. I'm not looking for an argument about that, I'm looking for a possible balance to the spell progression of wizards/sorcerer in regards to the undead summoning spells.

If you have alternative ideas those are welcome. smile

~O.R.
Back to top
mylittlepwny
5:02:48 am GMT 02/13/11
mylittlepwny Zesty Mordant
Registered Member #1223 Joined: 8:21:47 pm GMT 12/16/07
Posts: 7023
Yeah, the ghoul sucks. It's very discouraging. It would be nice if it was useful.

Unfortunately we don't have the builder power right now to do anything with spell adjustments.

Current active build staff is two people, and we both work full time, so we're mostly focused on stuff that is completely broken, and plot-related requirements.

Insert usual line about "if you know anyone who knows how scripting works and has scads of free time and would like to look over a backlog of stuff going back two years, PM me".
Back to top
Dontella
5:09:43 am GMT 02/13/11
Dontella Registered Member #1004 Joined: 12:54:02 pm GMT 03/16/07
Posts: 2499
I believe this was already tinkered with, previously. As seen here: -Clickedy-

Given we are talking for an arcane caster, A level 8 spell requires a level 15 casting requirement. This is the wight and one level from the spectre. At level 16 the spectre kicks in. The spectre has had, previously from Miggen, a massive boost to the creature to make the spell a great deal more useful.

I'm uncertain if he fiddled with the other critters, but there was some work done on the spell previously.

Edit: Had my levels wrong, d'oh!
Back to top
ArezimaRedwind
5:22:03 am GMT 02/13/11
ArezimaRedwind Registered Member #442 Joined: 8:50:19 pm GMT 02/24/05
Posts: 972
While Create Undead is often thought of as an eighth level spell, it's worth noting that clerics also receive it as a sixth level spell. Ergo, altering it to work like Create Greater Undead would be rather problematic.

It certainly is too weak by default, though. I haven't fussed around enough with the current version on Thain to comment beyond that.
Back to top
OccamsRazor
5:45:24 am GMT 02/13/11
OccamsRazor Registered Member #1490 Joined: 5:13:40 pm GMT 11/12/09
Posts: 71
Thanks for the replies, feel free to lock this thread, that's all I was looking to learn. smile

~O.R.
Back to top

Moderator(s): TheSiteMaster, Kira, Wicked_Keen, Bonesly, jewwe, Warlord Kro, Corlupi, Cuchuwyn, Gh0StF1sH, Alanonas, Oberon, Forgiver, serbiris

Go to:

Forum theme loosely based on Invision Power Board
Online
  • Guests: 62
  • Members: 0
  • Newest Member: Anya178mn
  • Most ever online: 4393
    Guests: 4393, Members: 0 on Sunday 26 April 2026 - 05:03:09
Now Playing
1. Kassia
2. Cecania Nimelle Coraline
3. Shivruin Te'Qashi
Connect to us with 104.237.156.142 or thain.no-ip.org